How often do our fears about a conversation turn out to be completely wrong?
In a recent Leadership Story Talks debrief, hosts Jerome DeRoy and Julienne Ryan reflected on a powerful moment shared by former CIA officer and leadership coach Kenny Leahman.
It’s a story about courage.
It’s a story about trust.
And perhaps most importantly, it’s a story about the assumptions we carry into some of life’s most important conversations.
Walking Into the Room
Kenny described a moment that had been weighing on him for years.
After serving in a career where hiding a fundamental part of himself felt necessary, he made the decision to come out to a former boss—a highly respected leader, former Marine, and imposing figure who had played an important role in his career.
Kenny was terrified. He traveled specifically to have the conversation face-to-face because he believed it mattered that much. As he entered the office, his mind was already writing the ending.
Rejection. Disappointment. Disapproval.
The relationship he valued so deeply might be over. But then something unexpected happened.
After Kenny finally shared the truth, his former boss stood up, walked around the desk, and hugged him.
No lecture. No judgment. No rejection. Just acceptance.
And in that moment, years of fear collided with a reality he never saw coming.
The Assumptions That Hold Us Back
One of the themes Jerome highlighted in the debrief was how often we create stories about other people’s reactions before they ever happen.
We assume we know how someone will respond.
We predict rejection and brace for conflict. We imagine worst-case scenarios.
Sometimes those fears are grounded in real experiences. Sometimes they come from past disappointments or cultural expectations.
But often, those stories live entirely in our heads.
Kenny’s experience is a reminder that the narrative we create before entering a room is not always the truth waiting for us on the other side of the door.
When Your Actions No Longer Match Your Values
Jerome also pointed to something deeper in Kenny’s story.
For years, Kenny was carrying a secret that placed him at odds with his own values.
At some point, the cost of hiding became greater than the risk of being honest.
Many of us experience a version of this. Not necessarily around identity, but around careers, relationships, leadership decisions, or personal goals. We find ourselves living out of alignment with what we truly believe. And eventually, something has to change. That moment of truth often requires enormous courage because there are no guarantees.
We don’t know how people will respond or what comes next. We only know that staying hidden is no longer an option.
The Leadership Lesson in a Hug
One of the most striking aspects of Kenny’s story wasn’t his courage.
It was his former boss’s response.
In leadership conversations, we often focus on communication techniques, difficult conversations, or conflict resolution strategies.
Yet this leader didn’t rely on a carefully crafted speech.
He simply recognized what Kenny needed in that moment. Empathy, presence and human connection.
The relationship they had built over years of trust mattered more than any assumption Kenny had made about how the conversation might unfold.
It’s a powerful reminder that leadership isn’t always about having the perfect words.
Sometimes it’s about showing up in exactly the right way at exactly the right time.
Trust Is Built Long Before the Moment Arrives
Looking back, it’s easy to see why the hug made sense.
These two men had worked together for years.
They had built trust in high-stakes environments where trust wasn’t optional.
Yet fear can make us forget history.
When we’re vulnerable, we often focus on the risk in front of us rather than the foundation beneath us.
Kenny’s story reminds us that the relationships we’ve invested in over time may be stronger than we realize.
And that trust often reveals itself most clearly in life’s defining moments.
A Question Worth Asking
Toward the end of the debrief, Jerome offered a challenge.
Think about the moments in your own life when someone showed up for you.
Not necessarily with a grand gesture.
Not with a perfect speech.
But with exactly what you needed.
A word. A conversation. A vote of confidence and a hug.
Those moments may have lasted only seconds. Yet they often shape the direction of entire careers, relationships, and lives. The people involved may not even realize the impact they had. But years later, we still remember and tell the story.
Because those moments remind us of something important: Sometimes the biggest obstacle isn’t the conversation we’re afraid to have. It’s the story we’ve already told ourselves about how it will end.
Experience The Listening Lab
Great leaders aren’t just great communicators—they’re great listeners. Start your free one-month trial of The Listening Lab and strengthen one of the most valuable leadership skills you’ll ever develop:
